distributing modified source code


(tjw) #1

I’ve tried to read the License.rtf file that is included in the WET_Source.exe file, but my non-lawyer brain is having problems understanding it.

Is it allowed to publically release source for a mod? If not the full source, are unified patches (diff -urN) against the original allowed?


(bacon) #2

There was a thread on this a while ago, but it got off-topic.
I think you can pack your modified files into an archive, at-least that’s the way many people in the Q3 community did it.


(Rain) #3

The license is quite contradictory. Depending on how you read it, you aren’t allowed to distribute any sort of modification at all. :suspicious:


(bacon) #4

Are you referring to 2J??
That’s a funny line :smiley:


(SCDS_reyalP) #5

I distributed source and no one has sued me yet…

There are also source-available quake3 mods, and none of them have had any trouble. Given the history, I suspect even if someone did suddenly decide to pull a SCO, they would have a lot of trouble doing anything more than ordering you to stop distributing it.

Just MHO. I’m not a lawyer, if you want legal advice, go hire one.

Note that the GTKradiant license has similar problems. It actually only allows you to make stuff for quake3, not any of the other games it support :moo: paraphrase quote from ttimo “yeah, we should fix that, but we have more important stuff to do”

edit:
Note that trying to put the modified source under a different license, use it with some other game, or sell it would be more likely to get you in trouble, IMO. Any new code your write is completely your own, of course.


(Rain) #6

Yeah, 2J exactly.

I agree that what most people are doing is unlikely to see any trouble (and it’d be PR death to turn around and start stabbing people like that), but it’s still annoying. :disgust: