Bf2142= 8vs8 or 10vs10
Quakewars= 6vs6
If a game wants to be a big clangame it has to be playable at lans, and 6vs6 is.
Quakewars is allready a better clangame. And the modscene for ET is just so much better than the modscene in BF, if you see it from a clanplayers perspective. ETpro was just so fucking great, ETtv++ Havent seen anything like that in bf.
And anyways, some bf clans may play 2142, but after 2 weeks they will find all the bugs and crap from betafield2 and they will quit 2142. Remember, each patch adds new bugs, a bf game cant be played for more then a year anymore, after that its just to many bugs.