I’ve seen a lot of people claiming that Sawbonez is strictly better than Phoenix, but I think they’re missing one important aspect of Ph and that’s that he can heal teammates WHILE they’re taking damage.
If your teammate is on low health and is taking heavy fire with little to no cover, you can’t heal him with a Sawbonez med pack - as soon as he starts the healing process all it takes is one bullet for that process to instantly halt and for the medpack to be wasted. On the other hand, Phoenix can instantly heal that low health teammate by a considerable amount and have their health gain even if they take a bullet immediately after the pulse.
It’s just one more benefit to Phoenix that I don’t think gets mentioned enough.
That said, I’m still unsure which of them is the best medic in the game…