Why do you think so?
[/quote]
Phantom is self-explanatory, absolutely useless in a 5v5 environment.
Vassili is no longer the broken powerhouse he used to be, and while he retains his ability to one shot, his heartbeat is considered weaker than Red Eye’s IR. While he is not useless, and still picked, I see a lot more people opting to use Redeye due to his additional health pool and abilities.
Red Eye on the other hand has an infinite spotting ability that lasts 4 seconds, and the ability to smoke and ping people with a far greater chance at killing them than they have him. The PDP and smoke combo has been shown to be downright frustrating to fight in the right hands, because the only counter to it is to straight up not engage him in a fight, and while this can also be said with Vas, you have a far greater chance at taking out Vas than you do a target that you can’t even see. At the same time his entire team will know your location and this will be refreshed every single time you engage Red Eye, due to how the IR cooldown works. Heartbeat can be removed and needs regular redeployment, IR does not - in a typical game, the enemy is spotted nearly all the time, and this only changes when the Red Eye is dead, or they are.
Red Eye wins out due to the clip size, damage, rate of fire, and lack of real penalty on missing with his weapon. Each headshot is 90 damage, you can effectively remove an entire team at a much faster speed, and this is what happens when Splash Damage balance the PDP with the pre-nerf instagibbing bolt actions, which no longer do so. This weapon can, statistically, perform at a far better level than either bolt action right now, which leaves the question of “why would you ever use it?”
If and when they nerf the PDP we’ll most likely see a return to a primarily Vassili recon style, as the bolt actions will again become the go-to weaponry for picking off the team.