Custom Map Review Site!


(Velorum) #21

heh, actually i didn’t see the banner when i visited the site so don’t take my post offensively. From what i could see your website lacked a banner and i was willing to help ya out and give ya one…but agreeded your current banner will do nicely. And just let me know how you want me to contact you and i will hook you up with my reviews and we can average our scores to give people a better idea of how good each map is or isn’t.

Also i like your new method of breaking down scores. However…each section is graded on a 1 to 5 basis and the overall is graded on a 1 to 10…so your not taking a true average of each aspect of the map…and you are still basing your overall grade on your personal feelings. I think you should broaden your individual aspect scores to a range from 1 to 10 and then average all the individual aspects to form an overall score but again it is your decision and i like what your doing with the site a lot :clap:


(evillair) #22

A very well done review site (for quake3) was BigHouse. You can check a review here; http://planetquake.com/bighouse/reviews.asp?id=143

I’d also recommend checking his ‘about’ page where he let’s you know how he reviews maps.

I personaly like the way he did his reviews.

Of course, you can do whatever you want, just stating what I like. :slight_smile:


(SirLiveAlot) #23

Nope. overall is an average. I added up the four catorogries and divided it by 2 to get an average out of 10. I did that so i don’t get wacky decimal places if it was out of 5. I will put that info somewhere in my site when i have time.


(SaBBeS) #24

Hi really cool site!

Would love to see some ‘map in progress’ stuff :wink: like Secret Operations , Indiana Jones and Venice map for instance.
More ‘real’ screens from the maps would be cool too…

Keep the good work up! Added it to my favorites!

Cheers :drink: